What an Insurance Brokerage Website Needs: Pages, Trust Signals and a Quick Path to a Quote
By Ali Sedighi, MBA · Last reviewed November 2026
An insurance brokerage website has to do three things quickly: show which kinds of cover you arrange, show that real, licensed people stand behind them, and make it simple to ask for a quote. Visitors arrive in the middle of a task, such as buying a home, renewing a policy or answering a client's request for a certificate, and they leave if the path is unclear. This guide lists the pages, features and details that matter for a brokerage, the way to handle quote forms and claims information, and the mistakes that quietly cost requests and referrals.
Key points
- Build a page for each line you write, including commercial classes, so visitors recognise their situation and see that you understand it.
- Show named brokers, licence details and how the brokerage works with carriers, since many visitors are deciding between a broker and a direct insurer.
- Keep the quote form short and offer a phone number as an equal option, because many people want to talk to someone about cover.
- Include a claims page that explains how the brokerage supports clients, written carefully so it does not imply any claim will be paid.
- Test every page on a phone, since many visitors arrive from a search while standing in a rental unit, a driveway or a job site.
In this guide
- What do visitors need to see right away?
- Which pages should an insurance site include?
- How should quote forms be designed?
- A first 30 days of improving the site
- How should claims information be presented?
- Security, privacy and accessibility
- Measuring the site in brokerage terms
- Rules and context for brokerages in Canada
- Common mistakes
- How we help insurance brokers
- Frequently asked questions
What do visitors need to see right away?
A visitor should understand within seconds that this is an insurance brokerage, which kinds of cover you arrange and how to start. A plain headline, a short list of the main lines and a visible quote button and phone number do the job. Large stock photos of families under umbrellas tell visitors nothing and push the real content down.
Show the brokerage name, licence information where your regulator expects it and a real photo of a broker or the office. People deciding on a broker want to know that a person will answer. Keep navigation simple, with entries for personal, business, claims, about and contact, instead of long menus filled with carrier names or product jargon.
- Brokerage name and licence details on every page
- A real photo and name for at least one broker
- A phone number that can be tapped on a phone
- One clear invitation to request a quote
Which pages should an insurance site include?
Start with a page for each line of business you actively write. Each should explain who the cover is for, what it generally includes and excludes in plain terms, what information a broker needs to quote and what happens after the request. Avoid premium figures and any statement of savings, which vary and are risky in advertising.
Add commercial pages for the classes you really serve, such as contractors, restaurants, retailers, consultants or landlords. Include a how-we-work page, a claims support page, broker profiles and a resources page with checklists. Each page should link to the quote form and show the same phone number, so the path to contact is never more than a click away.
- Home, condo and tenant insurance pages
- Auto insurance and renewal review page
- Commercial pages for each class you serve
- Certificates of insurance and what clients should know
- Claims support and how the brokerage helps
- Broker profiles with licence details and focus areas
How should quote forms be designed?
A short form with name, phone, the type of cover and a convenient time to call lets visitors begin without effort. Every extra field loses people, so collect detailed information such as vehicle details, building characteristics or revenue during the quoting conversation. Explain why each question is asked and how the information will be used.
Offer separate forms or form paths for personal and commercial requests, since the questions differ. Show a confirmation that says who will respond, by when and from which number, so the visitor will recognise the call. Make sure submissions reach a named person promptly, and test the form on several phones before launch.
- Name, phone and type of cover as required fields
- A preferred time to call that brokers honour
- Separate paths for personal and commercial requests
- A consent line explaining how contact details will be used
A first 30 days of improving the site
In week one, use the site on a phone as a stressed first-time homeowner would, and list every moment of confusion. In week two, rewrite the home page and the two most important line pages. In week three, add or improve broker profiles, the how-we-work page and the claims page. In week four, shorten the forms, test every contact route and confirm that requests arrive and are answered quickly.
After that, review monthly. Look at the pages that precede quote requests, add a missing class page when a pattern appears, and update checklists when carrier requirements change. Keep a short log of changes so that you know what was altered and when.
- Week one: review the site on a phone and list problems
- Week two: rewrite the home page and top line pages
- Week three: add profiles, how-we-work and claims pages
- Week four: shorten forms and test every contact route
How should claims information be presented?
Claims are when clients judge a broker, and prospects often look for reassurance. A claims page can explain the steps a client should generally take, how to reach the brokerage and the insurer, and how the broker supports the client. Keep it careful: do not imply that any claim will be paid or settled in a particular way, since that depends on the policy and the insurer.
Provide clear contact details, hours and any after-hours instructions that the carrier requires, taking care that the information is current. Link to the carrier's own claims contacts where appropriate. Review the page when carriers change processes, because stale claims instructions cause real harm to clients under stress.
Security, privacy and accessibility
A brokerage site collects personal information, sometimes including driving histories, property details or business financials. Use a secure connection throughout, keep software updated, limit access to form submissions and avoid asking visitors to send sensitive documents through ordinary forms. Use secure upload or your brokerage management system for documents.
Accessibility is part of trust. Use readable type, strong colour contrast, clear labels on form fields and keyboard-friendly navigation. Publish a plain-language privacy statement explaining what you collect, why, how long you keep it and how someone can withdraw consent or request access.
- Secure connection across every page
- Privacy statement linked from every form
- Secure upload instead of ordinary form attachments
- Readable type, clear contrast and labelled fields
Measuring the site in brokerage terms
Visits are a weak measure. Track quote requests, calls, quotes delivered and policies bound, and look at which pages sit before those actions. Watch the proportion of visitors on phones, since a form that works poorly on a small screen shows up as missing requests. Use call tracking where appropriate and be open about it.
If a page has visits but no requests, it may not answer the visitor's question or offer a clear next step. If form submissions go unanswered, the problem is process, not design. Read actual enquiries monthly alongside the numbers to see what visitors are asking for that the site does not yet provide.
Rules and context for brokerages in Canada
Insurance sales are licensed and regulated provincially, and website content counts as advertising. Regulators may expect licence details, may restrict how savings, comparisons and testimonials are presented and may require disclosures. Check your regulator's current advertising standards and have a licensed broker approve public copy.
Canadian privacy law applies to the personal information you collect, and anti-spam rules require consent before you send marketing messages. Use plain consent language on forms, avoid implying that coverage is automatic and never promise an outcome on a claim.
Common mistakes
- Using a template full of generic insurance imagery, with no named brokers, no licence details and no explanation of how the brokerage works with carriers.
- Placing a long quote form on the first screen that asks for vehicle, property and financial details before the visitor has decided to talk to anyone.
- Listing premium examples or savings statements that may conflict with advertising standards and quickly become out of date as carriers change pricing.
- Leaving form submissions in a shared inbox where each broker assumes another has called back, so the visitor waits and requests a quote elsewhere.
- Publishing outdated claims instructions, which can send a stressed client to the wrong number or process at exactly the moment they need clear help.