Ali Sedighi
Insurance brokers · Google Ads

Google Ads for Insurance Brokers: Campaign Structure, Quote Forms and Cost Control

By Ali Sedighi, MBA · Last reviewed November 2026

Google Ads lets an insurance brokerage appear when someone searches for home, tenant, auto or commercial cover, or for a broker who can compare options. It rewards structure: one campaign per line of business, a landing page that matches the search, a quick quote request, and tracking that follows enquiries through to bound policies. It also demands care, because insurance clicks can be costly, many searchers are only price shopping and advertising is regulated. This guide covers account structure, which searches to buy, how to write compliant ads, how to control cost and how to judge results.

Key points

  • Build separate campaigns for home, auto, tenant and commercial cover, because each has different search wording, urgency and value.
  • Commercial classes such as contractors or restaurants allow tightly targeted ad groups, and these enquiries are often worth more per policy.
  • Many searches come from price shoppers, so negative keywords, tight locations and a clear explanation of the broker's role protect the budget.
  • Track calls and quote requests, then match them to bound policies to learn the real cost of acquiring a client.
  • Avoid savings, comparison or approval wording unless your regulator's advertising standards allow it, and read Google's current policy for your category.

In this guide

  1. Which searches deserve your budget?
  2. How should the account be structured?
  3. What should the ads and landing pages say?
  4. Setting up your first campaign, step by step
  5. Why is cost control harder in insurance?
  6. Measuring results in brokerage terms
  7. Rules and context for advertising in Canada
  8. Common mistakes
  9. How we help insurance brokers
  10. Frequently asked questions

Which searches deserve your budget?

Searches that name a line of business and a clear need are the closest to a purchase: home insurance for a new purchase, tenant insurance to meet a lease requirement, general liability for a contractor, or help with an auto renewal. Broader searches such as cheap insurance attract price shoppers who may never talk to a broker, and these usually deserve a smaller share of spend.

Start where your brokerage is strongest, since that is where quoting is fastest and carriers are most receptive. Review the search terms report weekly and keep a list of phrases that produced bound policies. Be wary of competitor name searches and of terms where a client expects a direct insurer, since conversion tends to be poor and some practices can raise policy issues.

  • Home and condo insurance for new owners
  • Tenant insurance and proof of coverage for leases
  • Auto insurance renewals and quote reviews
  • Contractor, trades and small business liability
  • Commercial property and rental property cover

How should the account be structured?

Create a campaign for each line of business and ad groups inside it for tight themes. A commercial campaign might include ad groups for general liability for contractors, restaurant insurance and professional liability for consultants, each with its own ads and page. This matching of search, ad and page raises relevance and makes results easier to read.

Limit locations to where your brokers are licensed and able to serve. Set ad schedules around hours when someone can answer, or use call extensions only during those hours. Add negative keywords for careers, licensing courses, claims numbers for other insurers and free quote tools you do not provide. A tidy account is easier to improve than a sprawling one.

  • One campaign for each line of business
  • Locations limited to licensed areas
  • Call settings that match staffed hours
  • Negative keywords for careers, claims lines and unrelated products

What should the ads and landing pages say?

Describe what you do and the next step in plain terms: a broker will review your situation and approach carriers on your behalf, if that is how your brokerage works. Avoid promising savings, lowest prices or certain coverage. Comparative statements about direct insurers or other brokers can breach advertising rules. Show the brokerage name and licence details where expected.

The landing page should repeat the search, list what information is needed for a quote, explain what happens next and offer a short form and a phone number. Ask only for what you need to begin, such as name, phone and the type of cover. Add consent wording for follow-up messages and a brief note about how personal information will be used.

Setting up your first campaign, step by step

Pick one line of business to start. Build or refresh the landing page, test the form and phone number on a phone, and confirm that both calls and submissions are tracked. Then create one search campaign with a small group of phrase and exact match keywords, two or three ads, limited locations and a daily budget that you can afford to learn with.

Check the search terms report after a week and add negatives. Review again each week for a month. Pause terms that produce clicks without calls. Add a second line of business only after the first has produced enough data to judge. Keep a change log, so that you can link shifts in results to what you changed.

  • Choose one line of business with real capacity
  • Build and test its landing page and tracking
  • Launch a small search campaign with tight locations
  • Review search terms weekly and add negatives
  • Add the next line only after reading results

Why is cost control harder in insurance?

Insurance keywords can be expensive because many firms bid and a client may stay for years. Your click cost reflects competition, ad relevance, landing page quality and location. You cannot change the market, but you can avoid waste: remove poor search terms, narrow locations, match schedules to staff and send clicks to relevant pages.

Use a formula based on your own numbers. Estimate the value of a bound policy, including likely renewals, the share of quote requests that bind and the share of clicks that become quote requests. Working backward gives a ceiling for cost per click. As an illustration only, if a policy is worth a certain amount over its life, the brokerage can decide what portion to risk to acquire it.

Seasonality also shapes spend. Tenant and home searches rise around moving periods, while auto renewals follow the calendar of earlier policies. Review last year's quote requests by month, and plan budget and staffing for the busier weeks so calls are answered when the ads perform.

Measuring results in brokerage terms

Track calls above a minimum length, quote requests, quotes delivered, policies bound and renewals retained. Link call tracking to campaigns and record the source on each new client in your system. The numbers that matter most are cost per quote request and cost per bound policy, with attention to the line of business, because commercial and personal policies differ in value and effort.

Also check enquiry quality. A campaign that produces requests for coverage you do not write, or from outside your licensed area, is wasting money however good the form count looks. Ask brokers to mark poor-fit enquiries and use that information to refine keywords and text.

  • Calls, quote requests and quotes delivered by campaign
  • Policies bound by line of business
  • Share of enquiries that fit your carriers and licensed area
  • Renewal retention for clients won through ads

Rules and context for advertising in Canada

Insurance sales are licensed provincially, and advertising is subject to regulator and professional standards. These may cover how savings, comparisons, coverage and testimonials are described, and what licence information must appear. Read your regulator's current advertising guidance and have a licensed broker or compliance lead approve ads and pages.

Google applies its own advertising policies to financial and insurance services, which vary by country and category, so check the current policy for your category. Canadian privacy and anti-spam rules require consent for marketing messages, and forms should explain how personal information will be used.

Common mistakes

  • Sending all clicks to the home page rather than a page that matches the line of business, the trade or the lease requirement the person searched for.
  • Writing ads that promise the lowest price or certain coverage, which advertising rules may restrict and which can mislead people about what a broker can arrange.
  • Leaving locations broad so ads show outside licensed areas, which brings enquiries that cannot legally be served and wastes budget.
  • Counting every quote request as a win without checking whether the risk fits your carriers, the broker's capacity or your preferred client types.
  • Pausing campaigns after a short test because policies have not bound yet, when quoting, decisions and renewal timing in insurance can take weeks.

How we help insurance brokers with this

This guide explains how the work is done so you can do it yourself or check what a supplier is doing for you. If you would rather hand it over, these are the services that cover it. We are a marketing and business consultation company led by Ali Sedighi, MBA, working for insurance brokers. We are not a insurance brokerage ourselves.

Google & Social Advertising

Campaigns aimed at the searches and audiences most likely to become paying customers.

Digital advertising

Conversion Rate Optimization

Get more business from the visitors, callers, and ad clicks you already have.

Conversion rate optimization

Website Design & Development

A fast, clear website built to turn visitors into calls, bookings, and quote requests.

Web design & development

Frequently asked questions

How much should an insurance brokerage spend on Google Ads?

There is no standard figure. Work backward from the value of a bound policy, including likely renewals, your quote-to-bind rate and the number of quotes your brokers can handle well. Begin with a modest test budget, learn from search terms and increase only when results and capacity support it.

Is it better to advertise personal or commercial insurance?

It depends on your carriers, expertise and capacity. Commercial enquiries are often more specific and can be more valuable, while personal lines produce steady volume and renewals. Many brokerages start with the line where they can quote fastest, then expand once tracking shows what works. Whichever you choose, check that carriers and capacity can support the volume.

Why do I get clicks but few quote requests?

Common causes are generic landing pages, long forms, price shoppers, broad locations or unanswered calls. Review the search terms, test the page on a phone, shorten the form and check response times. Compare quote requests with clicks for each campaign before changing budget. Segment results by line of business before drawing conclusions.

Do I need call tracking?

Many insurance enquiries begin with a call, so without tracking you miss much of the picture. Call tracking connects calls to campaigns and keywords. Make sure callers are told if calls may be recorded, and follow privacy rules for how recordings and numbers are handled. Use call recording only where the law and your privacy policy allow it.

Can I use savings claims in ads?

Savings and comparison claims are commonly restricted, and results vary by person, so they are risky. Check your regulator's current advertising standards and Google's policy for your category. A safer approach describes what a broker does and invites a conversation about the client's situation. Keep any example you use general, and invite the reader to request a quote for their own situation.

How we work

  1. Step 1

    Free consultation

    A conversation about the business, its goals, and how customers find and contact it today.

  2. Step 2

    Review and plan

    We review the website, search and AI visibility, advertising, and enquiry handling, then set priorities and a budget.

  3. Step 3

    Build

    A senior strategist leads the work and a specialist team delivers it: pages, tracking, campaigns, automation, and CRM.

  4. Step 4

    Measure and improve

    Calls, forms, bookings, and their sources are reported plainly, and the plan is adjusted to what the numbers show.

Written and reviewed by Ali Sedighi, MBA

Ali Sedighi leads a digital marketing and business consultation company based in Vancouver, British Columbia, with 17+ years in marketing and technology. Work is senior strategist-led and delivered with a specialist team. Read more about Ali and his credentials.

Last reviewed: November 2026. This page is general marketing guidance, not legal, financial, medical, or technical advice.

Want this done for your insurance brokerage?

Book a free consultation. We will look at how clients find you now, where enquiries are being lost, and what to fix first.

Ali Sedighi, MBA · Vancouver, British Columbia · Ali@Sedighi.ca

Contact Me

(604)632-4959Ali@Sedighi.caLinkedInBook a CallContact Form