Ali Sedighi
Contractors · Guide

HomeStars vs Houzz: which platform suits your contracting business

By Ali Sedighi, MBA · Last reviewed November 2026

HomeStars and Houzz serve different moments in a homeowner's decision, so the right choice depends on the work you sell. HomeStars is a Canadian directory built around reviews of home service companies, where people look for a trade to hire for a defined job. Houzz is an international platform built around design photography, where people collect ideas for renovations and find designers, builders and renovators through their portfolios. Repair, maintenance and single-trade companies usually feel more at home on the first. Design-led renovators and custom builders usually fit the second. Many businesses keep a free profile on both and pay for neither until a tracked trial justifies it.

Key points

  • HomeStars centres on reviews and hiring a trade, while Houzz centres on photos and design inspiration.
  • Match the platform to your typical project: defined service jobs or design-led renovations.
  • A complete free profile on each is a sensible starting point before any paid commitment.
  • Ask about contract length, lead sharing, service area and cancellation before signing for anything paid.
  • Judge either platform on your own cost per booked job over a fair trial period.

In this guide

  1. What is the basic difference between HomeStars and Houzz?
  2. Who uses each platform, and what do they want?
  3. Which kinds of work suit each platform?
  4. How to build a strong profile on either one
  5. Paid options: what to ask before you sign
  6. A 90-day way to evaluate either platform with your own numbers
  7. Where directories sit beside your website and Google profile
  8. Notes for Canadian contractors
  9. Common mistakes
  10. Frequently asked questions

What is the basic difference between HomeStars and Houzz?

HomeStars is organised like a directory. A homeowner chooses a category such as roofing, plumbing, painting or fencing, sees a list of local companies, and compares them mainly by reviews and ratings. The platform also lets homeowners describe a job and receive responses from companies. The question it answers is practical: who near me does this work, and what did their past customers say.

Houzz is organised around images. People browse photographs of kitchens, bathrooms, exteriors and gardens, save the ones they like into collections, and then look at the professionals behind those projects. Its directory covers architects, interior designers, design-build firms, general contractors, cabinetmakers and garden designers, among others. It also offers business software for professionals. The question it answers is earlier and broader: what could my home look like, and who creates work like this.

Who uses each platform, and what do they want?

The typical HomeStars visitor has a job in mind and is close to hiring. They may need a fence replaced, a basement waterproofed or a house painted, and they want reassurance about reliability, tidiness and price fairness. They read written reviews closely. Because the platform is focused on Canada, the audience and the company listings are local to Canadian communities.

The typical Houzz visitor is often months from starting. They are gathering ideas, forming a budget and deciding on a style. When they contact a professional, the conversation is usually about a larger project with design decisions involved. Houzz draws an international audience, so only part of the attention a portfolio receives will come from your service area. Neither audience is better. They are at different stages and respond to different proof.

Which kinds of work suit each platform?

Start from your average job. If most of your revenue comes from defined, repeatable services that a homeowner can describe in a sentence, a review-led directory matches how your customers choose. Speed of response and a deep bank of recent reviews are your advantages there. If most of your revenue comes from projects that begin with a design conversation, a portfolio-led platform matches the way your clients shop, and photography is your advantage.

Plenty of companies sit in between. A renovation contractor who does both bathroom refits and full additions can make a reasonable case for each. In that situation, build both free profiles properly, see which one produces enquiries of the kind you want over a few months, and let that evidence decide where any paid effort goes. Guessing in advance is rarely as accurate.

  • Review-led fit: roofing, painting, plumbing repair, fencing, paving and similar single-trade jobs
  • Review-led fit: maintenance work where trust and punctuality drive the choice
  • Portfolio-led fit: kitchens, bathrooms and whole-home renovations with design input
  • Portfolio-led fit: custom homes, additions, millwork and outdoor living projects
  • Either: general renovation companies with a mix of small and large projects

How to build a strong profile on either one

A thin profile wastes the visit. On HomeStars, the foundations are accurate categories, a clear description of the services and areas you cover, photos of real jobs and a steady flow of genuine reviews from recent customers. Ask clients at the end of each job, follow the platform's review rules, and reply to what they write. A profile with a handful of old reviews looks dormant beside one that received feedback last month.

On Houzz, the portfolio does the selling. Upload complete projects instead of single images, with professional or carefully taken photographs, a short description of the brief, and details of materials and scope. Organise projects by room or type so a visitor can find work like their own. Reviews matter there too, as does answering questions that people leave on your photos.

  • Company description stating services, areas served and years in business
  • Categories chosen for the work you want, not every job you could do
  • Projects shown as full sets with a few sentences of context
  • Recent reviews requested from real clients under the platform's rules
  • Licence, insurance and warranty information stated accurately
  • Prompt replies to messages, questions and reviews

A 90-day way to evaluate either platform with your own numbers

Opinions about directories are strong and contradictory, because results vary by trade, area and how the contractor handles enquiries. The only evidence that should move your budget is your own. Run a deliberate trial: complete the profile, respond quickly to every contact, and record each enquiry from first message to final outcome. Three months is a reasonable minimum for service work, and design-led projects need longer because they take longer to sign.

At the end, calculate cost per booked job by dividing everything you paid, including the value of time spent, by the number of jobs signed. Then look at the quality of those jobs: their size, their margin and whether the clients were a good fit. Compare the figure with your other sources before renewing, expanding or stopping, and write the result down for next year.

  • Use a dedicated phone number or ask every contact where they found you
  • Log each enquiry with date, job type, area and platform
  • Record whether you reached the person and booked an estimate
  • Record signed jobs, revenue and gross profit
  • Divide total platform cost by signed jobs at the end of the trial

Where directories sit beside your website and Google profile

A directory profile is rented space. The platform sets the layout, shows competitors beside you and can change its rules or prices. Your own website and your Google Business Profile are the assets you control, and they should carry the full story: services, service areas, project galleries, credentials and contact details. Use directories to be present where homeowners already look, and send interested people back to your own site where there is no competitor in the next row.

Keep the details consistent everywhere. The same business name, phone number and service description on each platform avoids confusion and supports your local search presence. Spread your review requests too. Google reviews generally reach the widest audience, but a contractor with feedback on several platforms looks established wherever a homeowner checks, and is less exposed if one platform changes its rules.

Notes for Canadian contractors

Because HomeStars is a Canadian service, its categories and audience reflect Canadian homes and seasons, and coverage tends to be deeper in larger urban regions than in rural areas. Check how many homeowners and competitors are active in your own community before judging its value. On Houzz, filter your thinking to local enquiries, since admiration from another country does not fill a schedule in Manitoba or Nova Scotia.

In Quebec and other French-speaking markets, write your profile in the language your clients use. When you invite clients to review you on any platform, make the request part of completing their job, and do not add them to promotional lists without consent that meets Canada's anti-spam rules. Get written permission before publishing photographs of a client's home, and remove anything that reveals the address.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing a platform because a competitor is on it, without asking whether its audience matches your typical project.
  • Signing a paid agreement after a phone call without reading the term, the cancellation clause and the service area.
  • Creating a profile with three photos and no reviews, then concluding the platform does not work.
  • Replying to directory enquiries the next day, after the homeowner has already heard from other companies.
  • Building the whole marketing plan on a directory while the company website and Google profile stay neglected.

Frequently asked questions

Is HomeStars or Houzz better for a renovation contractor?

It depends on the renovations. If you mainly do defined jobs such as bathroom refits or basement finishing that homeowners compare on reviews and price, HomeStars is the more natural fit. If your projects start with design and your photographs are strong, Houzz suits you. Many renovators maintain both free profiles and let tracked enquiries show which deserves more attention.

Do I have to pay to be listed on HomeStars or Houzz?

Both have offered free basic profiles alongside paid programs, but the details of what is free and what is paid change, so confirm the current arrangement on each platform's site. A sensible approach is to complete the free profile fully, collect reviews and photos, and only consider paying once you have seen some organic interest and understand the written terms.

Are leads from these platforms any good?

There is no general answer, and anyone who gives one is describing their own experience. Quality depends on your trade, your area, how many companies receive the same enquiry and how fast you respond. The fair test is to track every lead from a platform for a few months and compare the cost per booked job with your other marketing sources.

Can I ask my existing customers to review me on HomeStars or Houzz?

Yes, and you should, provided the reviews are from real clients describing real work and you follow each platform's review policy. Send the direct link shortly after the job is finished. Do not offer rewards for positive reviews or write them on a client's behalf. A steady trickle of honest reviews carries more weight than a sudden batch.

Should I put my marketing budget into directories or Google?

Treat directories as one channel among several. Your Google Business Profile, website and search advertising reach homeowners at the moment they search and are assets or accounts you control. Directories add presence where some homeowners prefer to compare. Fund the channels you can measure, start small on anything new, and move budget toward whichever source shows the lowest cost per booked job.

Written and reviewed by Ali Sedighi, MBA

Ali Sedighi leads a digital marketing and business consultation company based in Vancouver, British Columbia, with 17+ years in marketing and technology. Work is senior strategist-led and delivered with a specialist team. Read more about Ali and his credentials.

Last reviewed: November 2026. This page is general marketing guidance, not legal, financial, medical, or technical advice.

Want this done for your company?

Book a free consultation. We will look at how customers find you now, where enquiries are being lost, and what to fix first.

Ali Sedighi, MBA · Vancouver, British Columbia · Ali@Sedighi.ca

Contact Me

(604)632-4959Ali@Sedighi.caLinkedInBook a CallContact Form